WARRIOR = NOBLE? WRONG!!!
Quote:
"A violent and...race!" It seems to me these Andorians weren't much as warriors, sure they could beat up Archer while he was in a chair, but he and Tucker pretty much mopped the floor with them when they got into hand to hand.
You're crying foul at every term, Phantom. To their culture, they are warriors. They don't have to be noble or chivalrous (you put too much stock into it compared to our Earth counterparts), especially when dealing with non-Andorians.
At least they got what they came for (evidence of a treaty violation between their species and the Vulcans) and leave without further altercation.
You think they should have superior martial skills over anyone they encounter? Not necessarily but they are trained.
AFAIC, I like this portrayal of the Andorians in Archer's timeline (22nd Century) as much as I like the portrayal of Klingons in Kirk's timeline (TOS 23rd Century). I would even go so far to say that they should be ENTERPRISE main villains, with the Vulcans being uneasy allies.
I give "The Andorian Incident" a 9 stars of out 10.
Revenge of the space pirates...
They're telling a terrible story
But it doesn't diminish their glory
For we'd be watching it if it was written
by their six year old daughters...
MISSION OBJECTIVE ACHIEVED
Quote:
Eh. Well, I was disappointed that the Andorians were basically little more than thugs...
I wouldn't call them thugs. They're soldiers, not necessarily gentlemen soldiers. They went in and got what they needed to get and left. At least they kept Archer's crew and the Vulcan monks alive. I wouldnt. (What can I say? I'm a Klingon at heart.) :cool:
If the Vulcans have some complaint about the incident, they can either go through diplomatic channel or retaliate in kind.
Hopefully we will see more of the Andorians. That one episode alone can't fully describe the bulk of their society any more can you describe Earth's diversified cultures.
Re: MISSION OBJECTIVE ACHIEVED
Quote:
Originally posted by REG
Hopefully we will see more of the Andorians.
You get your wish...Shran himself will be back (presumedly with more Andorians in tow) in an ep that goes before the cameras in a couple of weeks (this according to press releases on several sites).