Enterprise tried it: "Well, this time, we're in the past, at the birth of the Federation!" The show was plagued by poor writing and thin characterization until this past season, where things started to pick up.
Is it just me, or do each of the 'new' Trek series (TNG, DS9, VOY and ENT) seem to have this problem?
Each show was panned to varying degrees at the start, and then proceeded to get better (and in DS9's case ALOT better) as the series progressed. Obviously, people can look back on shows with hindsight and ask "What went wrong/right?" but just for once, even if to be original, cant we have ST where it is written well from the start?
B5 is a good example of this tactic. Sure, there were poor episodes, but, more often than not the writing and characters were generally of a superior quality. I think a defined story arc is really needed these days. We seem to have progressed from the episodic 'alien/techno-thingy' of the week format.
Cheers
Tas
I'm NOT stupid, I'm NOT expendable and I'm NOT going!