WOW Getting even better in my opinion!
Poor 1
2
Below Average 3
4
Usual Average 5
6
Above Average 7
8
Best of Enterprise 9
With the Best of Star Trek 10
Registered User
WOW Getting even better in my opinion!
Draftsmen in Training
Registered User
Wasn't as good as the first episode in this arc; It was kinda slow in the middle. But, the last 5 minutes changed things and put a real twist to the story.
So, I gave it a 9.
"The American Eagle needs both a right wing and a left wing in order to fly."
-paraphrase of Bill Moyers
Registered User
Yeah really great episode gave it 9 too.
Sometime a week seems like an eternity
Romuald "Pantoufle" Theate
Registered User
Da...is given 9
Beware those who march beneath the raptors wings.
A brave little theory, and actually quite coherent for a system of five or seven dimensions -- if only we lived in one.
Academician Prokhor Zakharov, "Now We Are Alone"
Registered User
Yeah. . . they use NUKES !Originally posted by BouncyCaitian
Da...is given 9
Beware those who march beneath the raptors wings.
"The American Eagle needs both a right wing and a left wing in order to fly."
-paraphrase of Bill Moyers
Registered User
As well as a reference to something else?
Draftsmen in Training
Registered User
Maaaaaybe.....
A brave little theory, and actually quite coherent for a system of five or seven dimensions -- if only we lived in one.
Academician Prokhor Zakharov, "Now We Are Alone"
Registered User
Loved this episode, actually gave it a 10. Keep it up
Garet
Registered User
The episode was really good too. Nice plot, nice pace. Gave it an 8. Two minor gripes:
- Soval's 180° backpedalling ... I can understand how dealing with humans for a while changed his mind a little, I can see how a human giving his life to save him changed his mind some more, but after his behaviour in "Home", I found his siding with humans way too quick. They should have showed a more progressive, more reluctant cooperation, it'd have been all the more believable.
- I still don't quite understand why the High Command (well, the Administrator mostly) needed to deal with the Syrrannites that urgently. I mean, as long as they did not have Surak's writings, they posed little threat to the Administrator's plans to attack Andoria. They were but another minor faction with an alternative version of Surak's teachings. Risking a war with the Humans if they were discovered, just so that they could hunt the Syrrannites down looks like a gross overkill to me.
Still, good solid episode.
Every procedure for getting a cat to take a pill works fine -- once.
Like the Borg, they learn...
-- (Terry Pratchett, alt.fan.pratchett)
Registered User
I found this episode to be decent but found it also to be predictable. It is too bad that it was Archer that carried Surak but that has to do more with the next episode and the overall arc.
Regards,
CKV.
"It is our mission to push back the darkness from the light and expand the boundaries of knowledge and understanding. That doesn't mean exploring every pleasure planet between here and Andromeda XO."
Posting Permissions
Reply With Quote