After much deliberation, I am starting a new Star Trek campaign, after having run FASA many years ago.
I am actually getting keyed about it. I intend to start in the NG/DS9 era, and if there is enough interest, go retro back to the original series era.
I decided to go with the ICON system for a few reasons.
With the officially published materials, and the materials available online for ICON, ICON "feels" more complete, and more fully realized.
Everything needed to play the game is in the ICON Core books, and they are just _packed_ with information. On the other hand, the CODA books don't seem terribly well organized.
I find ICON more easier to grasp. CharGen is simple and pain free. Easy, intuitve rules for task resolution. CODA, on the other hand, seems like it was trying to emulate D20, a system that I have never been enamored with.
Finally I am still irked with Decipher: if they had shown even a little concern about me as a customer buying their product, I might have supported them more. "As we say on Earth, C'est le vive!"