I also think that Decipher should try to use this award to increase their sales, but I am sceptical about the game really being the best one. As far as I know the only basis for selecting the winner is the number of online votes. I believe that any RPG based on a popular movie or series will atract more players, who, as long as the game doesn't have any major flaws, will vote for it. I don't know what other RPGs you were able to vote for, but I am sure that the producers of those games didn't have too high expectations after Decipher's application.
Don't misunderstand me, the LOTR RPG certainly is good, but the only way to find out if it is the best would have been by having an impartial jury.
“Worried? I’m scared to death. But I’ll be damned if I’m going to let them change the way I live my life.” - Joseph Sisko - Paradise Lost