Chello!
Excellent on savig Isildur and being at the "Heart of the Court"--but Galadriel is a Ringbearer as well....would Isildur be able to use the full power of the One against her, as Sauron could?
And what of the Nine? Sauron may be without form, but are the Nine powerless? How would they view a Ring-using Isildur? Would the Witchking try to get the One for himself?
Alternate histories are the ONLY way to play in a famous Universe. Out of the many Star Wars games thatI've ran over the years only one (my first) was set in "Uncle George's" Galaxy. In fact, in one campaign the SW films themselves were Rebel propaganda about people who existd. Think Rambo (well, he didn't really exist, but there was a Vietnam War, a US, green berets, etc--you get the pic, I'm sure).
Tony
Anthony N. Emmel, M.A.
Learned Scholar & Catholic Gentleman
U.S.S. Victory NCC-1760
"England expects that every man will do his duty."